Rotten Apple, Evil Google, Human Microsoft

As a Microsoft fan (and I tend to think I am quite knowledgable about their products and technologies too), I often find the articles describing the company as evil simply wrong or unfounded. Most times the author doesn’t make an adequate argument, or will argue something that is factually incorrect. Other times, the author neglects to point out something important that reflects positively on the company.

Also infuriating are the seemingly endless articles of praise written about Google and Apple. Lately there has been some comfort in the fact that bloggers have taken Google to task over it’s controversial AutoLink feature, but the vast majority of content written about Google is praise – sound or not. Apple is no different. The company behind the incredibly popular iPod is always placed on a pedestal. Recently though, things have begun to change.

People are now beginning to question whether Google really can do no wrong. AutoLink is a great example. Why is Google not being as harshly criticized as Microsoft was for its similar SmartTags feature from a few years ago? The blogosphere has been asking this question in huge numbers. With Google hiring everyone from operating system designers, to browser developers, to fibre optics experts, why are there no Microsoft-like conspiracy theories about Google taking over the world? Here too, bloggers are beginning to wonder.

Apple might be starting to fall off the praise train a bit too. People are finally starting to realize what a dead end the iPod platform is – one device, one store. Where’s the consumer choice there? And this excellent Forbes piece talks about Apple and their bullying of late. Perhaps the iPod success has inflated the egg-like head of Jobs even more?

Finally, Microsoft has begun to seem more human and friendly. With people like Robert Scoble assuming the role of public face for the company, Microsoft has begun to seem kinder, and more willing to work with others. I think people are starting to realize that the company isn’t so bad after all.

Combine these three developments and what do you get? A positive outlook for the already incredibly successful Microsoft, a potential crack in the strategy of Apple, and a more closely-watched Google. Who would have guessed such an outcome two years ago? Certainly not me.

12 thoughts on “Rotten Apple, Evil Google, Human Microsoft

  1. People aren’t complaining about google because they have a long track record of being fairly trustworthy. Microsoft on the other hand, has a history of competing via business trickery as much as via the strength of their products.

  2. You are correct. But my argument is that what you have described is changing! And people shouldn’t just trust Google because when they were a private, growing company they were trustworthy. They have shareholders now, and that makes a big difference. There is more than just Page and Brin to answer to.

  3. Yeah, and I’m sure Microsoft was innocent of bullying when it came to that Internet Explorer program?

    One store, one product? Are you serious, is that all you could come up with (no surprise, you’ve already killed any idea of non-bias when you sounded off that you are a microsoft fan)? It sounds to me like you wish that Apple would let other companies (gasp! Microsoft) sell the music for iPod users. But it’s not like Apple is the only one making and selling those songs available for download. If they were, then you might have a point. Have you used an iPod? You can put MP3’s, and music from your own album collection onto an iPod. Saying the iPod is a dead-end product is the same as calling all other mp3 players dead products.

    Lighten up a little.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s